Reflecting on the Goldwater Rule
In this episode we discuss the genesis of the Goldwater Rule, an internally enforced tenet governing the ways psychiatrists can comment on public figures. We then discuss hypotheticals (some close to home) to examine how this rule maintains an important position in our political system and question if any parts of it should be revised.
In this episode we discuss the genesis of the Goldwater Rule, an internally enforced tenet governing the ways psychiatrists can comment on public figures. We then discuss hypotheticals (some close to home) to examine how this rule maintains an important position in our political system and question if any parts of it should be revised.
Watch on YouTube: @itspresro
Listen Anywhere You Podcast: Apple, Spotify, PodChaser, etc.
—
Produced by Dr Glaucomflecken & Human Content
Get in Touch: howtobepatientpod.com
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Margaret: [00:00:00] The question gets to the ethics of how much evidence does someone in one institutional form of power, which is medicine, how much evidence do you need to see to question another institution and to put at risk your own institutional power if they're connected at all?
Preston: Welcome back to Halloween episode number two. We are still in costume and- ... strutting forward. or these are the truest versions of ourselves. The one day we're not in costume, some would say, is Halloween.
Margaret: That's when the truth comes out.
Preston: Yeah. Not everyone says it, but some people do say it. Well, today I am driving, and we have a, a fun episode where we are going to be talking about psychiatry in the political sphere.
Sometimes psychiatrists are active in the political sphere of their own volition, and sometimes they are brought into it. Most of the time it's somewhere in between. We've had a lot of psychiatric cases, that you may notice in the political sphere recently, but we're gonna talk about one actually way back in the middle [00:01:00] of the 20th century, and we'll be talking about good old Goldwater.
So we're gonna kinda plug right along today. we've already been doing our icebreakers from the last session but, before we start, Margaret, what does, the term Goldwater mean to you when you hear it as a soon-to-be full-blown attending psychiatrist with, I'm sure many opinions about the public world?
Margaret: Yeah. I mean, I think to me, I know the background of, the case and why this happened, and I think listened to an episode a while ago about it on, the Psychiatry and Psychotherapy podcast. Shout out David Puder. We'll get you on... We need to reach out to him and be like, "Come on our podcast, please."
Dream guest. but beyond that, I think it's the thing that is most commented under, like, when people go start to, interpret things or comment on, celebrity or whatever, just, public figures' mental health and I'm liking those comments that are like, "This person gets it." [00:02:00] Like, why are you diagnosing this, person who you don't know, you haven't met, and, you're using the field credibility, in this way, which has become more and more common in the age of social media.
Preston: Exactly, like people think that they can repost a viral video and say, "This person's clearly having a manic episode. Look at me, I'm a psychiatrist, and I think this is what it looks like." I think that's where I see it the most, where it may be well-intentioned and someone's trying to be educational, but it's one thing to say, "This is an example of what a manic episode could look like" when it's a TV show character or when it's not someone who's, in real life and actually may be, like, brought to trial or under press for their actions that are then, caught on a phone.
So I think it extends more than just do I think this political figure is psychotic or not? which is where it kind of was at the beginning. So we're gonna be talking about the, the history of the Goldwater rule, the, original, scandal, and then kind of go into a little bit actually of some of the comments that [00:03:00] psychiatrists said at the time because- Oh
this is something that was new to me. I didn't actually see how they responded to it.
Margaret: Mm-hmm.
Preston: And, kind of bring that into, what it's our responsibility, with some kind of hypothetical situations going forward. So when we get back in just a moment, we will get started with the case.
Margaret and I are very excited to tell you about a healthcare news podcast that just came out called Medlines.
Margaret: It's a quick weekly wrap-up of everything in our field, from breakthrough discoveries and research, to politics and, of course, medical pop culture.
Preston: I think the best way to conceptualize this podcast is it's like NPR's Up First, but for medicine.
So they're short, to the point, with episodes no longer than 15 minutes.
Margaret: And it's written and created by an amazing team, some of whom you might recognize: Dr. Glaucomflecken and Lady Glaucomflecken, as well as many people here at the Human Content Podcast Network.
Preston: With thanks for their inaugural sponsor, the New England Journal of Medicine.
New episodes of Medlines are out wherever you get your podcasts, with new episodes out every Friday.[00:04:00]
So Barry Goldwater, he was this, the Republican, nominee from Arizona at the time, and he was, running for election in the 1960s. he was a, a prominent, a Republican figure. He wrote a book in the early 1960s which was called, The Consciousness of a Conservative. And he was actually, decently good friends with Kennedy and throughout the early 1960s, and then a lot of that changed when Kennedy was assassinated, and there was kind of like a hole on the opposition.
That's when Lyndon B. Johnson entered the scene, and a lot of people described LBJ's tactics as ruthless and, scrappy, kind of willing to do anything he could to take the win, and that included, seeking out different magazines to write hit pieces [00:05:00] on Goldwater. So, so the, what started out as this kind of cordial back and forth between, Kennedy and Goldwater, which is I think how Goldwater thought it would go, it, shifted to more of, a mud fight or a dust-up when LBJ, started- A dust-up.
Oh ... his election. And-
Margaret: The internet recently discovered that... I'm sorry. I'm, like, laughing. the internet recently discovered Lyndon B. Johnson was hot at one point. Oh, my God. the other thing is my friends and I in high school had to write a rap based on history, and we made one about Lyndon Johnson, and it's still in my head like 10 years later.
So I'm just like, "That guy." Fun fact, he gave a pope of him- or he gave a bust of himself to the pope at the time. That's just- Yeah ... that's just who he was. It's how he rocked. Sure, sure. Anyway, continue. I'm sorry.
Preston: And he also, I remember hearing stories like LBJ h- was kinda like strange with his staff. Mm-hmm Overly friendly with- Lyndon Johnson
like he would, he'd have them like walk into the bathroom with him or something.
Margaret: Yeah, he's so fresh. [00:06:00] He's the 36th president of the US. He served from '63 to '69. All the ladies go, "Lyndon, you're so fine." That was our wrap.
Preston: Oh my gosh.
Margaret: Okay, sorry. I'm so sorry. Continue.
Preston: No, So, there's this magazine that was started in 1964, January 1964, called Fact Magazine, and their whole thing was...
Yeah, Fact. Except they were kind of fringe, and Fact Magazine was willing to kind of run the stories that, maybe other more reputable sources weren't willing to. So, in 1964, their January issue, they started out hot with a hit piece on Goldwater already. And let me pull that up really quick. Sorry. this doesn't come out...
It's, a lot of these actually old magazines are hidden, but they, started out just running like different political pieces in early January. But then in June is when they really hit the main piece, which is- Mm-hmm ... they run this, story called The Unconscience of a Conservative, and that's on Barry Goldwater, and it's [00:07:00] making fun of his old piece that he wrote, The Consciousness of a Conservative.
And what they said was, "We surveyed, like 1,189 psychiatrists and found that he's unfit to be president." But what it, what this... The article actually isn't, it's not a summary of all the opinions. They've actually list out all 1,000 responses from the psychiatrists. So I want to take a second and go through some of those readings and reactions from them because I found them really fascinating.
So, and some of the psychiatrists actually, like they either psychoanalyze or some of them like lean in, try to comment on psychopathology or they moralize. Mm-hmm. A lot of it's like from their position as a psychiatrist. So this is from Alan M. Levy, MD, New York, 1964 I think Goldwater has a paranoid personality which shows itself by marked rigidity, a tendency to [00:08:00] project blame, fear of internal impulses breaking out, and inherent contradictions in almost all of his statements.
I feel he's dangerous because, though compensated at present, he could and probably will be more irrational and paranoid under political attack during the campaign. He is very much like Senator McCarthy.
Margaret: not a senator you wanna be compared to. Shout out McCarthyism from AP US History. Learning.
Preston: and then now we have a positive one right below this.
My mother-in-law's ranch is 20 miles from Johnson City, so I've had some intimate glimpses of Johnson and have the lowest regard for him. I am for Goldwater. So the other thing about this article is that they had some people, would reply and just straight up hate on the magazine, and they- Mm-hmm
they just, published all of it. So-
Margaret: Well, they're equal opportunity at Fact Magazine.
Preston: Yeah. Yeah, no, Fact Magazine doesn't care. So here's one
Margaret: from- The original no-spin zone.
Preston: From, [00:09:00] Robert J. Curie in, Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Please arrange for an appointment for Senator Goldwater with our office at his earliest convenience and mine.
At that time, I'll be pleased to do a psychological evaluation, as this is the only way a proper evaluation can be done.
Margaret: Let's go. Let's go that one.
Preston: And then, we have the very next psychiatrist right below this. "From his published statements, I get the impression that Goldwater is basically a paranoid schizophrenic who deco- decompensates from time to time.
His judgment is often very poor and his outbursts of impulsive aggression I find quite frightening in a potential president. In addition, he seems to be shallow and unable to empathize with many groups of people. Name withheld, MD from Boston."
Margaret: Well.
Preston: So yeah.
Margaret: Clocks-
Preston: Who knows to say that- ... to clock ... who that might be?
Okay, and then there's a couple more basically that are, like, analyzing his childhood. So some are saying that, his [00:10:00] misogyny may extend from, his relationship with his dad or his mother and, some of them are trying to, take more of a psychodynamic lens on this. last one I think sums it up well.
"While I believe it is unfair for me as a psychiatrist to make comments on a personal- personality, personability based on public pers- public appearances only," I swear I'm not too tongue-tied. I think the, beard's getting in the way. "I also feel that the issue is so important that even a reasonable doubt as to the candidate's ability to perform should be stated.
I definitely don't think Barry Goldwater is fit to serve as President of the United States." So this, I think is at the core of why this became a problem, and it's has two parts of it. So they even acknowledge that it's, hard for them as a psychiatrist to make diagnostic statements, but then they go back and they lean on their authority as a psychiatrist to say this person isn't fit to be president.
So the story runs in June of [00:11:00] 1964. He later loses the election in a complete landslide and then sues Fact Magazine for defamation, afterwards. There's, The trial was Goldwater versus Ginsburg, and the court found that, they favored with the defendant. They, Said that it was acknowledged they were publishing defamatory statements and were motivated by actual malice when they published the statements.
They found the defendants had libeled Senator Goldwater, and while the plaintiff demanded $1 million in compensatory and punitive damages, Senator Goldwater was awarded $1 in compensatory damage and $75,000 in punitive damages. and then the compensatory damages were split between all the other defendants.
But the important thing that came out of this for us is that the APA or the American Psychiatric Association, which it had been around for about 40 [00:12:00] years, formerly the APA was formed in about 1920. But the, the split between the American Psychiatric Association from, neurology was still rather fresh, and they made a rule that it was, no longer possible or that psychiatrists should not comment on the, physical fortitude, psychiatric pathology of public figures after that.
What's interesting is that the APA, the American Psychological Association, did not take on that rule as well. So it's something that only, applies to psychiatrists at this point. And-
Margaret: Doesn't that apply to psychologists now? Didn't they make their own version of it?
Preston: I don't think it's as strong.
Margaret: S- that would make sense.
Preston: So the, the American Psychological Association doesn't use-- They don't adopt the Goldwater rule, but they have their own, ethics policy
Margaret: On commenting publicly
Preston: Yeah. about using, like making remote or armchair diagnoses. [00:13:00]
Margaret: Okay.
Preston: So they have something similar. It's generally considered an ethical violation, yeah.
Margaret: So they sound similar, but you can see where you can imagine where this gets messy because I guess the other part of this is like apparently, and you maybe mentioned this in w- related to neurology, but that like the American Medical Association was apparently invested kind of in Goldwater. was more c- at that time, thought to be more of a conservative body and wanted Goldwater, as part of its like lobbying.
And so then the psychiatrists had split off and been like, "I'm f that guy."
Preston: Yeah. It, wouldn't be the first time that psychiatry has kind of been the, the red-headed stepchild of the American Medical Association and their- Allegedly.
Margaret: Yeah. ...
Preston: their drives. Yeah. But I mean, this is, this is-- it's only 1,000 psychiatrists speaking out, but I think the other thing that's interesting about this, there's only like 10,000 psychiatrists in the entire country at the [00:14:00] time.
Margaret: So- It's a pretty significant amount ...
Preston: they got 10, around 10% of- Yeah ... all practicing psychiatrists to weigh in at one point on this.
Margaret: I can't get one to call me back.
Preston: Yeah, no, for real.
Margaret: I can't get one collaboration. Yeah. Well, and then the question of n- ethic- no ethical value lives across medicine, not just in psychiatry, lives in a silo.
So and maybe this is where, we'll go, like it's like, and on one hand, I can draw up a great case as to why this was a bad thing, and then when this person was not psychotic or anything, it makes psychiatrists look super biased and the field look super biased and stuff. And you can imagine how this can really just make it so that like portions of the medical field or the mental health field don't feel very limited on having any engagement with like the social political component of what impacts our patients' health.
Preston: Yeah. And that's kind of where I wanted to go with this next. So we are gonna [00:15:00] take a quick break, and when we get back, we'll talk about how do we interface with public problems now.
So th- like the real reason why, or the one of the strongest reasons why the Goldwater rule interests me is because a lot of people ask me as a psychiatrist to weigh in on, current political issues. And I think part of it is because they see psychiatrists as, a reasonable and, moral person who's capable of investigating problems with nuance.
But I always have this rule sitting in the back of my head where I don't want to, go too far as to diagnose someone. But there are ways that you can comment on someone's character, their actions, without necessarily going to the realm of diagnosis. But I, feel like it almost-- I don't know if you feel this way, but it makes me feel like I have to be a bit, apolitical in my, public stance about things because people know that I am a psychiatrist, and they'll [00:16:00] see, my opinions of someone's character as a bit, diagnostic.
Margaret: Well, I mean, I think there's a different reason for why, like, how I show up online or how, I professionally think about this, and it's that I think there's a question of how do you value, who your social media or public presence might make it to, and how does that make certain patients and patient families for me in child more or less willing to work with you or able to work with you?
And then, what are your actual political values and how are they most effectively achieved? When it comes to politics, I guess I feel less limited by the Goldwater rule and in terms of, being able to speak on issues and representing psychiatry in that, broader stance. And I, mean, I wouldn't-- I don't really feel tempted to speak in any way on, really any politician.
I think it's, kind of dirty politics to, straw man people anyway. And so, maybe I'm just, more of a believer in, the [00:17:00] Mamdani style of kind of being like, "Can we go back to the issues?" versus, ad hominem, arguments. So I guess, I guess I don't really-- like, I can't imagine myself wanting to use the, weight of psychiatry to speak about a person specifically.
If it was like, "We're gonna put AI in the schools and we're gonna have all kids start with AI and not learn how to read, and, we think this is awesome," I, would feel strongly of, my clinical background makes me think that we should proceed with caution and make sure kids are getting good learning and things for their mental health.
And, that would be a political stance informed by my clinical work, but it wouldn't be a personal endorsement or diagnosis of a specific, personality of a politician.
Preston: Mm-hmm.
Margaret: What do you think, though?
Preston: So the I'm gonna bring up another news story. So this was in... Last I saw was in, in [00:18:00] 2025.
There was, a, an anchor on Fox 29 was diagnosed with skin cancer after a dermatologist who was watching the TV show called in and said, "Hey, I like, I recognize this lesion on your face, and I'm, like, pretty positive it's a basal cell carcinoma," I think is what it was. I'm not sure the exact type of skin cancer and, he was right.
I, guess, what I'm kinda getting at is, other specialties are maybe a little bit more free. Or not, free is not the right word, but they're-- There's this implication that, the things that they're doing is meant to be helpful when they're offering their diagnoses. But-
Margaret: Mm-hmm ...
Preston: I still has feeling that, like, when you're trying to, express that someone may have a psychiatric diagnosis, it's still, seen as a way to disparage them.
And I wonder if there's, i- if there's any future where we can say, "Oh, I think, this amount of, psychia- psychiatric diagnosis may be involved," but [00:19:00] it's not seen as, something that's, totally disparaging to the person.
Margaret: I'm gonna disagree with you on this here 'cause I, don't-- I agree.
I guess part of it I agree with that it's yeah, I mean, in theory, broadly, de-stigmatizing mental health and having psychiatry be valued and mental health in general be, like, seen as just, a part of the human condition like other illnesses. I don't disagree with that, writ large. But I don't think our diagnoses can be known from public-facing appearances and diagnosed in the way that, a dermatologist can see a particular mole.
Yeah.
And so I think that there's also a level to which, psychiatry has an issue as a field with understanding itself as, objective and not making strides towards understanding that there are core philosophic and moralizing things that we assume everyone shares, and paternalizing within our field or because there are lo- so many things we don't [00:20:00] know, and because there are, like, moral and cultural differences.
So agree with you, that let's not stigmatize or, say that this is not a valuable field or that mental health, should be something we're ashamed of. Don't agree with you that, there's a similarity of ability to diagnose as simply as there is of, recognizing a mole. Yeah. I- Or something like that.
No, I- Or, recognizing a thyroid ...
Preston: I think it's a great point, and it's, ultimately probably a weak metaphor to try to compare them. what about something in the middle, like maybe a neurologist that recognizes a Parkinsonian gait in someone?
Margaret: Yeah.
Preston: That, that may be, like, a more subjective middle ground.
Margaret: Yeah.
Preston: Is it inappropriate for that neurologist to... should they call in, say, "I think this is a Parkinsonian gait"? Do they-- The neurologists don't, as far as I'm aware, don't have the same Goldwater rule to openly come and say, "Oh, I think, you know, this person is showing sign- early signs of [00:21:00] Parkinsonism."
Margaret: Well, are they writing an op-ed, or are they calling that particular politician and saying, "Hey, I think you should be screened for this and seek care"?
Preston: Let's, do both scenarios. I'm inclined to say that the, them calling and saying "I think you should get screened for this," is fine and honestly probably very similar to the, the dermatologist
Margaret: Yeah, I agree.
Writing an op-ed and saying, "As a neurologist, this person has this illness," and implying with it that they are therefore not fit to serve-
Preston: Mm-hmm ...
Margaret: then I think you get into a similar ethical question that I th- the AMA I think has more broadly taken stance on, stances on since the '70s. So I don't know what neuro- if neurology has it named like that, but I can imagine if someone was, if a neurologist wrote an op-ed that was like, "I, I think this person has this illness that they haven't publicly talked about, and that makes them unfit, and their personality also indicates it," as a neurologist, they'd probably run into similar troubles.
At least I mean, I think, I guess is my [00:22:00] hypothesis.
Preston: Just curious, what your thoughts about this ethical dilemma. What if more than just Parkinsonism, what if you recognize signs of dementia-
Margaret: Mm-hmm ...
Preston: in somebody? And so this, is where I think it, it, kind of, becomes more of a quandary, right? If you have this duty to do no harm or, to prevent harm where you can see it, right?
it's obviously maybe disparaging to call into question someone's competency. But if you have this genuine concern that someone who is in charge of the nuclear football or could be putting their hand on the button or making these decisions about war is suffering from a neurodegenerative illness that's cognitively impairing them Do you have a responsibility to share that information that you have access to or can assess?
Margaret: But like people who are go into positions of power like are... I mean, like if we wanna say the entire system's like bunk, that's one thing. But like people are put through assessments for these positions. they are kind of put given evaluations [00:23:00] theoretically. And again, if we wanna say "Well, there's something else happening," blah, blah, blah, and these people are not actually assessing them, then like that's a kinda different conversation of public trust in the systems.
But in theory, let's say that those are also clinicians that are like good clinicians. My question, I guess, back to you would be if that is true, which I think we have to assume it's true for this conversation ethically speaking, what would a public non-specifically seeing this person as a patient neurologist, let's say.
what would be the purpose of them doing that? Unless it was to say "There's a conspiracy," and like we're doing like a Weekend at Bernie's type of thing in the, in a political position and there's I'm just, I'm trying to come up with a situation without assuming conspiracy. Where it's not conspiratorial.
Yeah.
Preston: Yeah.
Margaret: That it's like ethically... And maybe if it's 1930 and you're like, "This is a brand-new discovery we've made, about how the brain works."
Preston: Yeah, I don't know if I can, I don't know if I can either. I think, [00:24:00] 'cause I'm posing this question then I'm mulling it over in my head too.
Mm-hmm. And I think you're right that the only way that what the neurologist could be doing in a way that could be considered ethical is if you no longer have trust in the systems at play to screen for and detect these illnesses internally. I guess I don't wanna get too conspiratorial, but then that whole story came out, after, so the president that's coming to mind is President, Joseph Biden.
After he finished, his presidency, there's entire story about how much the Democratic Party was downplaying his memory problems. And that there was like possibly more of evi- like an ounce of conspiracy to it that we didn't see.
Margaret: But then your, the question gets to the ethics of how much evidence does someone in one institutional form of power, which is medicine, how much evidence do you need to see to question another institution and to put at risk your own institutional power if they are connected at all?
Which I don't say that as a s- way to say "Don't [00:25:00] ever do that. Be ultra like-" The, the original sense of the word conservative is, not change, not progressive, or not shaking the boat. But, I think that becomes an ethics calculation of, if s- if I know from within psychiatry, something really horrible is happening within our field or, whatever, and we're, like, actively under conspiracy, then the question becomes how, under a broken system where there is conspiracy, do I do the most good according to the ethical values I'm trying to uphold?
Which I, do think becomes kind of a plus/minus pros and cons calculation.
Mm-hmm.
And so if it was like, oh, well, there's a conspiracy, and then it's this, which, I'm not, you know, put on my, my- Your tinfoil hat ... my crown of ethics. Yeah. My
tinfoil
crown of hat ethics. Yeah. I think then that becomes a like, okay, we're living in an imperfect system, which is most systems.
What is, my individual ethics and, w- I, guess, the question is what would a neurologist do then in that? [00:26:00] what is... Are you suggesting in that kind of situation where there's some politician who this was, like, there was conspiracy. I guess, what makes that-- What makes you think of-- Where does that lead your mind in terms of these questions?
Preston: Hypothetical scenario would be there's a politician that is suffering from a neurodegenerative illness that appears to be, like, called into question by other people. There's a conspiracy that it's being c- like, covered up, and then they come in with their expertise to say, "No, I, agree. I'm seeing signs of this neurodegenerative illness."
It's not to ser- it's not to treat the patient in front of them. those, those cons all they have to serve a, a political purpose.
So it would... I think any of those, like, diagnostic statements or comments, th- they're all speaking truth to power, but they're not, I think, serving the role of being a physician if a physician's role is to treat the patient in front of them [00:27:00]
Margaret: Well, and then becomes the question of, I feel like these questions are so potent is because, in theory, it's this crossing over of, are you t- is your role as a physician in a system in advocating, which has become more important, I think.
I mean, it's always been important, but I think it's been more openly encouraged of, med students and physicians and stuff to be active in these different, social determinants of health and, therefore politics. But if you're using your diagnosing at the individual level tools to then use that person's potential illness as something that you use as a political tool, it gets really messy really fast.
And in theory, you can think of ways that it's, for the greater good and, you could imagine a bunch of different scenarios, right? But there is definitely a crossing of lines, and that is, I think, when the ethics get... you really have to not be sure, but, be like... The, it becomes a are the, a do the ends justify the means conversation.
Preston: [00:28:00] Mm-hmm.
Margaret: Life is just a bunch of trolley problems.
Preston: Yeah. Yeah, it really is.
Margaret: It's just a series of trolley problems in medicine.
Preston: A- and I think we've, we've seen some physicians kind of do the math on their trolley problem and, have come out and spoken about it in, in, in some in, direct violation of these rules.
So, you know how, a neurologist, if they diagnose someone with epilepsy, like they have a seizure, they have a duty to tell them to not drive. In some states, they can have their license suspended because they could have a seizure while they're driving. As far as I understand, that same, rule d- doesn't apply to us with psychiatric diagnoses.
Margaret: Well, we have Tarasoff. So not
Preston: psychiatric diagnoses, but- the the duty to inform for homicidal ideation.
Margaret: Yeah.
Preston: Right? But not necessarily for, competency.
Margaret: Right. Yeah.
Preston: Yeah. So, what d- what do you do if, let's say, you have a patient who's in charge of, they're in charge of, [00:29:00]
Margaret: I don't know- The hospital you're working in.
Preston: Yeah. Yeah. that's a good one. You have a patient, they're in charge-- They run the entire hospital, and they have decompensated, like s- new onset schizophrenia. It's a, 46-year-old woman, and she's having, delusions that have now progressed into, hallucinations, not responding to treatment.
Do you think that just, almost Instead of a Tarasoff rule for homicide ideations, do you think that there's any role for psychiatrists to break the patient-doctor confidentiality for questions of competence in public positions that relate to the, wellbeing of other people?
Margaret: I think there's certainly like law based on-- like sort of similar to Tarasoff that is like part of if I'm concerned someone is seriously gonna harm another person.
So let's say like this is someone who's like a surgeon and they're like, "Okay, I'm actively psychotic and I'm gonna go do another [00:30:00] surgery." Like those kinds of rules and laws apply to us and not, you know, given that I am dressed as a sin eater right now, are part of the fun ethics questions you ask in like Catholic apologetics of if a priest is told that the like cup he's about to go bless in the mass in confession is poisoned by a murderer, like the murderer comes to the confession, does it-- can he not drink it?
And the answer in Catholicism is no, he must drink it 'cause you must act as if, that had not happened. most places say that. Some people will say something different, but usually it's no, you have-- you can't-- at the very least, you can't go warn someone else. But we luckily in healthcare have that as a caveat that we do all the time when we meet with patients.
It's like if I'm seriously worried about you, I may do a wellness check. Like I may section you. I may call this person. So I think you then get into gradations where it's like they have an admin role at something that you're like, "That's kind of powerful. I don't know if they're gonna be great at doing that."
Then I don't think you have a like ethical [00:31:00] power to be like, "I'm gonna go try and get your job to understand that your reality testing is really poor, even though I think you won't be good and you might make some mistakes." If it gets to the level of where is the in-between for a really powerful politician or something and that and like they're your patient, I don't know.
I think you're at that point in like a Jack Reacher movie or something . Like the-- Like this senator is actually psychotic, and you are the psychiatrist that must decide if you do anything before he like tries to capture the vice president. Like we are in the action movies me and my parents watch at that point
Preston: Yeah. Yeah, true.
Margaret: Which is to say there's no ethical perfect choice there probably.
Preston: Right. And I feel like some people are like living that. Like that's, that's- Oh,
Margaret: for sure ...
Preston: probably some psychiatrists' reality right now.
Margaret: Mm-hmm.
And that's why you get supervision, friends.
Preston: Yeah.
Margaret: But I mean, we have questions of like a lesser extent ev- I mean, not lesser actually, but like you have a similarly [00:32:00] complex ethical question by if you have an outpatient at the end of this afternoon today, and they are someone who's like pretty chronically high risk, and they tell you something that is more concerning, but they refuse to go to the hospital, and they say they're fine, but they're suicidal.
Like I get that these are different ethical questions, but I would say the level of like risk and compromising of the different values that we hold up in medical ethics are similarly complicated. But we're used to making that ethical decision in psychiatry of "Okay, well, how much risk and is this worth it?
And what are our values? And what are the patient's values and the system's values?" So I guess just to say like there's always a calculating in ethics. In some problems, different people in the systems are more used to making those calculations.
Preston: Yeah. And, I think it's, the same principles that we're weighing.
You know, s- like the, the person who you may not perceive to be at the head of a large organization still has the capability to, cause a lot of harm if they were to unravel as someone we see at the reins of a large organization. So we're still balancing the same things. We just maybe, [00:33:00] because of our like political thoughts or identities feel that it changes the scale in some way.
Margaret: Well, and if we l- in a-- if we were in a different culture, like I mean even just being in state to state, there are different levels of the ability to place someone in a guardianship or place a section like state to state in the United States. Like-
Preston: Mm-hmm ...
Margaret: that we are so culturally bound to the point of Non-recognition in the field to recognize that, if you put us in a totally different time and place, then we would have different agreed-upon cultural values that we would then act by.
And the podcast episode in that alternate timeline would be like, one time a psychiatrist didn't speak about someone's neurocognitive status, and they were publicly shamed, and da, da, right? we could have different ethical values that we prioritize-
Preston: Mm-hmm ...
Margaret: to some extent, I think.
Preston: Yeah, no, I, agree.
It, comes back to the... May- maybe this [00:34:00] is an extension of the principle, like innocent until proven guilty, but it's almost like we'd rather have someone maybe slip by with an illness or a level of incompetence than have someone who's, in a good state of mind be, like, wrongfully diagnosed or accused.
Margaret: Yeah, exactly, I think.
Preston: And, that's, something that we've agreed upon as a society that, this is a hypothetical scenario that we'd rather tolerate.
Margaret: Yeah.
Preston: The implication of creating a world where psychiatrists or neurologists, whoever, have a moral duty, obligation, expectation to comment on the readiness and fitness of certain politicians means that will be a lever that will be so easily subjected to the powers that be.
Margaret: Yeah. I mean, I think, you know, I'm not a total, there is no meaning. You know, you and listeners know I'm not, a there is no meaning, there is no true morality, there is no, natural law or whatever. Like- People not die. like there's a lot that I think are bounded maybe [00:35:00] in like humanity of like not hurting one another, not causing pain, trying to connect.
But when it comes to these more complex ethical problems in modern life, I think there's a bunch of ways you could put things together that would make sense in terms of value systems that are not just the one we have, which is a mind fuck to think about.
Preston: Yeah. But- Yeah, no, absolutely. Y- if you change-- I mean, it's like you change a couple s- core fundamental rules about a scaffolding of laws that are built around it, the whole world's gonna flip.
it'd be like if, I don't know, if we made gravity like a fa- like a factor of 10 different, the, the entire world would be so, so like unrecognizable. Mm-hmm. And it's just because of one tweak of a fundamental law would extend to how the rest of the world reacts to it.
Margaret: Right. There's one other thing I wanna say just to circle back to what this episode is about, which is like there is a real possibility [00:36:00] that the silence of medical professionals in the last couple decades has also been a part of allowing bad things to happen to our patients and does violate our...
is an overvaluing of like autonomy in some ways and an undervaluing of do no harm and like beneficence. And so I just wanna say like for our listeners who are in this, like there is also a conversation about power and how we use or actively are passive about using that power, in medicine, that perhaps this rule has made us less active than we would've been and has not been a net like benefit in the total weighing.
I don't know. I think it's one example of that. Mm-hmm. But I just wanna acknowledge that there is also a question here about like power and dominance in society, that this rule makes us value it in a certain way, and that may or may not be ultimately to the benefit of society.
Preston: So are you saying that this rule has, made psychiatrist, psychiatry, psychiatric organizations [00:37:00] less politically active or less- Yes
willing to endorse certain-
Margaret: Yeah ...
Preston: candidates or policies that otherwise would be like common sense in the favor of like good mental health care?
Margaret: Theoretically, yes. Yeah. I don't think it's the only re- I don't think this rule is the only reason why psychiatry hasn't been active. I think there's a lot of stuff baked into the history of medicine and psychiatry that is-
Preston: Mm-hmm
Margaret: interesting to say the least, but Yes, I think that there's a, there is a way in which, and some people have written on this, that we are defanged and, made less active advocates than we could be, if rules like this weren't kind of the, pallbearers of, reticence in the field.
Preston: Yeah. And it, reminds me kind of like the Jedi in Star Wars.
Margaret: Same war.
Preston: there are a lot of really... I- in the Star Wars political verse, especially in, the earlier episodes, there's a lot of, terrible things that are happening, and people [00:38:00] try to draw the Jedi into the conflict with them, but they move very slow. They have another council meeting, they sit and talk, and, you know, that's, one of the qualms Anakin has.
Margaret: "Oh, like, all you people do is talk.
Preston: You know, you have the power to say something, but you don't." And the response they give back is basically, "Well," "dangerous stuff happens fast and, yeah, we could react, but to do things right, you have to do them slow, and doing things correctly takes time."
but silence is not moving
Margaret: slow. It's like E- the Ents in Lord of the Rings.
Preston: Yeah. No, it's exactly like the Ents in Lord of
Margaret: the Rings. The beard, we have decided.
Preston: what it... I'm pretty sure it's like they spend the first two days just, introducing themselves. We've
Margaret: all greeted one another. We've
Preston: finally finished our greetings. The
Margaret: Ents' last march. Sorry, okay.
Preston: Yeah. But to that point, [00:39:00] while they're moving slow, frustratingly slow, they're still marching. They're not just recusing themselves.
So I think I would be hopeful that, there's a way that we can march maybe a little bit more and, beyond the frustrating platitudes of just saying mental health matters. You know, these, I don't know, self-evident truisms that I think give people a sense of, like morality by just shouting, but, they don't, they're not aimed at anything or necessarily mean anything.
there are more specific problems that we could take stances on and- Yeah ... could use our expertise and power as psychiatrists to help the world.
Margaret: Yeah. I mean, I think for me, us having this podcast, was not cold water, but, is a risk in some ways, right? there's at least the-- you more so than for me in terms of, you being more face forward content, like, from the beginning and in med school.[00:40:00]
we have seen Good or bad, like the risks of doing stuff like being forward-facing and even just in the medical hierarchy, let alone larger society. And so, like I think, people are motivated to be more advocates, and I think the field itself is moving. And I think there's a recognition of we've talked about this, like there are things that I could...
In choosing to do this podcast, I'm not as blank slate-y as maybe would be best for some patients I might see, and you as well, right? but in my view of therapy, and that mistake or that, sacrifice of that value is worthwhile to me for the larger part of what I hope we do with this podcast. But I think reckoning with the fact that, you could be making a mistake and you are prioritizing one ethical value over another, and therefore you're- there's, you can't do 100% good by everyone-
Preston: Mm-hmm
Margaret: [00:41:00] is, an important thing. And not in a like, no one understands me," they're not gonna get... But in the like, "I could be wrong." I don't know. What will the balance show at the end of my life? Was it better, or was it part of misinformation or something? I don't know. You know, we can't know. And I think being able to state that, there might be some bad that you do by accident, and maybe you need to learn and do something differently.
Preston: I think the, the thesis of this podcast is that we're offering a more open forum in some ways to talk about stuff with good intentions without, fear-mongering. That hopefully most of the things we discuss are evidence-based, that we, I guess, combat misinformation. I think that's k- also kind of a vague platitude because we don't necessarily do takedowns of misinformation.
We just, I think, more promote ethical information. I- and that's, yeah, it's probably, more I would say how we do things. Factual. It's Facts Magazine. Yeah. Yeah, we're not like Fact Magazine, which, little note on them, they actually were disbanded three years later. It was, the magazine existed for a grand total of three years, [00:42:00] just long enough to shit on cold water- Just the facts for three years
and then exit. Yeah. They were like on- "We're telling sort of only facts, and then we're gone."
Margaret: But they got that sooner than Well, this has been an interesting discussion.
Preston: Thank you.
Margaret: I enjoyed this episode ...
Preston: I want to talk about harder things on the podcast, but I'm, but I too am, like, afraid of backlash by taking, more political stance.
even just mentioning, this was a huge New York Times piece about the Democratic Party covering up some of, Joe Biden's, memory issues. I feel, iffy even commenting on that, during this podcast. But I think there's still important issues that we need to discuss, especially since we're, like, one of the more, public-facing, I guess, psychiatrists at least maybe in, the podcast space.
Not that there's, not that the psychiatry podcast space is, extremely congested right now, but, we are voices out here that are discussing it. So, so I think it's important, but also [00:43:00] I feel iffy, going into that space.
Margaret: I don't know. I think thinking out loud and talking about these concepts is important, and I think there's lots of ways to kind of put the cart before the horse.
And so being thoughtful about it and slow, like the ants maybe, for good or for bad also makes sense, especially at this point where I don't know, maybe this is mine of just, like, where we- I'm almost done with training. But, I, guess a value I feel like we also hold for the podcast is, intellectual humi- humility, which recognizes, there may be reasons why people do what they do before us and why they haven't done this.
Mm-hmm. And
so saying, "Let me really learn," or, you know, "Let me find guests that have dedicated a lot of time to thinking about this to educate both our listeners and us." And even when, you know, in six months when I'm attending and a year and a half when you're attending, I feel like I'm still gonna be like, "I'm not an expert.
I'm just [00:44:00] riding here with you guys." I'm trying to get you information and do with that what you will and use the authority that we're given with our careers in this platform
Preston: well-ish.
Margaret: It's
Preston: so real, the acquiring more knowledge and then losing your sense of expertise because you can, actually appreciate how much there is to be-- to get wrong.
I, I guess one of my last comments as we're wrapping up, I-- now that I'm a fourth year and I'm interfacing more in the military space, I'm asked to comment as an expert on things. And I feel in some ways less confident- Wearing that ... than when I was an intern or PGY2. Yeah, I have to put the beard on for it.
Because- Let me think ... as a PGY2, I'd be like- ... "Oh, I've thought hard about the criteria and it's clearly this." And then now I
Margaret: can see-
Preston: When we started the podcast. Yeah. And now I can see all the ways these different- I
Margaret: was a four and you were a two.
Preston: it's like I've just been descending down the Dunning-Kruger curve as I, [00:45:00] get better, as I see more side effects, as I see more presentations of illnesses and I'm, like, trying to crawl back up and I'm like, "Dang," like, whenever I'm asked anything, all I wanna really say is, "I don't know," and how can anyone know anything?
And, what-- and, what even is knowledge? do you understand- What? Do you understand how com- Do you
Margaret: understand, son?
Preston: do you see how complacent we are every day when we claim to know these things that we don't know? And yet, yet the heartbeat of the world keeps beating. But we're all just-- we're all out here in our costumes.
You know? Until I, I finally came back into my true form as this prospector.
Margaret: And, you know what? That's the heart of the podcast. You and I could literally be experts on something 20 years from now and be like, "And you know at the end of the day's gonna end." Like-
Preston: Yeah ...
Margaret: I don't know. Like we do.
We've spent a long time. We know this more than someone selling you a supplement who's, you know, just started thinking about this hopefully. But, like- I think we [00:46:00] like just, you know, radical acceptance.
Preston: Yeah.
Margaret: All the things that we haven't thought about yet.
Preston: Is, and from the, like a few weeks episode with Jonah, one thing I'd like, I love to joke about with him is I'll be like, "Jonah, how does a neuron work?"
And he'll be like, "I don't know. I don't know the first thing about a neuron." this is a man, you know, who has, has a PhD in neuroscience.
Margaret: Yeah.
Preston: Like a
Margaret: leader in the field of
Preston: something. Yeah, exactly. And he gets like angry. He'll be like, "Nobody knows how the brain works. No one knows the first thing about the brain."
No one knows anything. Oh, I used to be annoyed when he said that. I'd be like, "Come on, you know something." And obviously he knows a lot about how it works, but, now I kinda get it, you know? Yeah. he's not gonna list off all the different ion channels in and out of it, and the fact that it has electrical sur- Like, to, presume how much you know about it.
he's speaking from a much more philosophical perspective and I'm like, I kinda get it now. Kinda get it.
Margaret: I just, I wanna ack- acknowledge the irony that I got this in the mail today from [00:47:00] Wash U. And the, the last 10 minutes have been both of us just crashing out and being like, "What is knowledge?
I'm not an expert. We don't know anything." This is the interview
they
did with me. It's like emerging leader. And I'm just like... And to sum up, the only reason I show that is just to be like, This is why we gotta stay with the papers and the experts and the leaders. Yeah. That's exciting. Thank you, Wash U, for liking the podcast and being like, "Yeah, what about health literacy?"
And then it's like getting back to it. what does good mean, and what does, it mean to think about the good?
Preston: Yeah. What, even is what? Remember-
Margaret: Period.
Preston: No- n- nobody knows what they're doing. the sun's setting tomorrow. Anyone who tells you otherwise is trying to sell you something.
But the people who say, "I don't know, but could be this," that's us. we're the, "I don't know, but could be"s.
Margaret: If they
Preston: can't give
Margaret: you a concrete, short [00:48:00] answer- ... they're probably closer to the truth.
Preston: Yeah. But we're thinking about it, and that's all that matters. All right,
Margaret: well- New podcast T-shirt merch.
Preston: Yeah. This was fun. thanks, for, following along to some of these, baked and half-baked ideas. shout-out to, to everyone who's been supportive of the podcast. I made a TikTok post about a psychoan- a- analysis fit, and somebody said, "Where Preston two years ago would be looking back on this," and-
I agree. I've c- we've come a long way. may- maybe I just need to read more about psychoanalysis and I'll figure out some of these problems. a- But if you, wanna hear, more from us, you can always find me @presro or Margaret @badoreveryday. The podcast is on Apple, Spotify, YouTube, in video and on audio, or you can listen to our episodes at howtobepatientpod.com.[00:49:00]
Thanks again for listening. We're your hosts, Preston Roche and Margaret Duncan. Our executive producers are me, Preston Roche, Margaret Duncan, Will Flanary, Kristin Flanary, Aron Korney, Rob Goldman, and Shahnti Brooke. Our editor and engineer is Jason Portizo. Our music is by Omer Ben-Zvi. To learn more about our program disclaimer and ethics policy, submission verification and licensing terms, and our HIPAA release terms, go to howtobepatientpod.com or reach out to us at howtobepatient@human-content.com with any questions or concerns.
How to Be a Patient is a Human Content production.
Thank you for watching. If you wanna see more of us or if you wanna see... This is Lilac. She's my cat. She's gonna be waving her hand at one of the floating boxes, which will lead to more [00:50:00] episodes. Lilac, point to the other episodes. Lilac doesn't know what the internet is, but I swear they're there. They pr- they probably exist for real.
But in the meantime, I'm just gonna pet Lilac, and then I'm gonna go dance in the background
RSS Feed